In my technology class we have been discussing WebQuests. There are so many free lesson plans and educational resources available online for teachers; however, we need to be careful and take time to evaluate the source and the information itself. The same is true of WebQuests, which are inquiry-based activities where students are using higher level thinking while examining information from the Internet. I came upon a social studies WebQuest for 2nd grade students. Using a checklist provided by my professor to evaluate this, I've found strengths and weaknesses in this particular activity.
Introduction
The scenario is that students are taking a hot air balloon ride over the world and they are to learn about the various land masses beneath them. This isn't brought up in the conclusion nor does it really tie anything together, but it does ask students questions such as, "Do you think there is a country for every letter of the alphabet?" which is something they will create as a class, an ABC book of countries.
I would say the introduction is okay but not great.
Use of Web
Students are grouped into continental teams to divide the research. There are a few websites for each group to find the information; however, most of them are from about.com or National Geographic (some of the links were outdated but you could tell where it used to be located). It would be better to incorporate a wider variety of websites and ones that are more kid-friendly. They could also have used music clips or videos from each region versus text only.
Question/Task
The work asked of students is grade appropriate. Students will collect information and individually report on a country and orally present as a group about the continent; however, this doesn't require much evaluation or synthesis as compared to just summarizing and retelling information.
Scaffolding
The directions are clear; however, it was not evident whether or not students were provided a graphic organizer to record their data. I would definitely include this for 2nd graders to help organize their information. I am also assuming the teacher is assisting students while they work in groups on their presentations.
Conclusion
The conclusion does not relate back to the hot air balloon story. It does sum up what they have accomplished and learned. It does not provide extra resources to continue learning about the regions, which I think would have been relatively easy to do and the students would enjoy.
Teacher Information
This section included all of the student objectives, what materials are needed, and examples of rubrics. It did not include information on how to differentiate by grade level, but I think it provided enough information if someone wanted to use this in their 2nd grade classroom.
Upon first glance, this seemed like a fairly decent WebQuest, but by taking a closer look, I've realized there were a lot of missing components that I would like to include when I create my own.
Sunday, March 14, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)